Skip to main content
Legal-only staffing for law firmshello@dockethire.com
Hiring

How to Hire a Legal Secretary: Pay, Skills Tests and Overtime Rules

2026-11-1916 min readBy DocketHire Team
legal secretaryhow to hire a legal secretarylegal secretary staffinghire a legal secretarylegal secretary serviceslaw firm hiringlegal support staffvirtual legal secretary

Hiring a legal secretary comes down to five decisions, made in this order: what the person will own, what you will pay, where you will look, how you will test, and how you will classify and supervise the hire. The median legal secretary earned $55,570 in May 2025 according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and the pool of experienced candidates is getting smaller every year, so a firm that posts a vague ad and interviews by feel will lose the good applicants to firms that move with a plan.

The hiring pool is shrinking

BLS counted 157,600 legal secretaries and administrative assistants in 2025 and projects 149,300 in 2035, a decline of 5%, or 8,300 jobs. Over the same decade it projects lawyer employment to grow 5%, from 863,700 to 904,300.

Put the two series side by side and the national count works out to about 5.5 lawyers for every legal secretary in 2025, heading to about 6.1 in 2035. That is arithmetic on occupation totals across every employer, including courts, corporate legal departments and government, so it is not a staffing benchmark for your firm. It does describe the market you are hiring in: fewer people hold the title each year, and the ones who remain support more lawyers each.

BLS attributes the decline among secretaries generally to technology that "enables staff in many organizations to prepare their own documents without the help of secretaries." The jobs are not disappearing through layoffs alone. O*NET, the Department of Labor's occupation database, still lists 18,100 projected job openings for the occupation over 2025 to 2035, and BLS says openings across secretarial occupations are expected to come from replacing workers who change occupations or leave the workforce, including retirees.

For a firm owner, a smaller pool changes the search. A posting that asks for ten years of litigation experience at an entry wage is competing for people who have other options, and it is worth deciding early whether the work could also be done by a hybrid legal assistant, a remote secretary, or two part-time specialists.

Decide what the secretary will own

BLS describes the job in one line: legal secretaries "prepare summonses, complaints, motions, subpoenas, and other legal documents" and work "under the supervision of an attorney or a paralegal." O*NET's task list fills in the rest: organizing documents and case files, arranging delivery of legal correspondence, preparing invoices, collecting employment and medical records, completing forms, scheduling, and handling calls.

No single hire does all of that well for more than a few lawyers. Before writing the ad, list the recurring work in your office and sort it into three columns.

Scroll sideways to see all columns.

ColumnTypical tasksWhy it matters for the hire
Document productionFormatting pleadings and briefs, tables of contents and authorities, exhibits, redaction, e-filing, serviceNeeds advanced Word and court rule knowledge. Test this directly.
Calendar and correspondenceDocketing hearing notices, scheduling depositions, client letters, court callsNeeds accuracy and judgment about what to escalate. A missed date here can become a malpractice claim.
Office and billing supportTime entry, invoices, expense reports, file opening and closing, travelEasiest to train and the easiest to move to a second person later.

Then write down the number of lawyers the person will support and the practice areas. A secretary who has spent a decade on residential closings will need months to become productive in federal litigation, and the reverse is also true. BLS notes that legal secretaries "may train for several months" to learn the vocabulary and practices of the field, and that is with a base of general office skill already in place.

If the list is mostly column one and column two, you are hiring a legal secretary. If it leans toward drafting discovery, summarizing records and managing cases, you are hiring a paralegal or legal assistant, and the comparison of legal assistants and legal secretaries will help you draw the line. The free legal job description generator turns the finished list into a posting.

Set the pay range from data

The BLS medians for May 2025 show where legal secretaries sit among administrative roles:

Scroll sideways to see all columns.

OccupationMedian annual wage, May 2025
Executive secretaries and executive administrative assistants$76,590
Legal secretaries and administrative assistants$55,570
Secretaries and administrative assistants, except legal, medical and executive$47,540
Medical secretaries and administrative assistants$45,930

O*NET lists the legal secretary median as $26.72 per hour. Half of the occupation earns more than that, so expect to pay above the median for someone who can assemble a federal appellate brief or run a trial exhibit list without help. Pay also differs by state and metro area, so look up your own in the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics tables before you settle on a number.

Wages are not the whole cost. A worked example at the national median:

Scroll sideways to see all columns.

ItemAnnual amount
Wages at the median$55,570
Employer Social Security tax, 6.2%$3,445
Employer Medicare tax, 1.45%$806
Subtotal before benefits$59,821

The 7.65% employer share comes from the IRS rates for Social Security and Medicare. Health insurance, paid leave, retirement contributions, federal and state unemployment tax, workers' compensation, a workstation and software licenses come on top. The legal staff cost calculator runs the same math with your own benefit figures.

Education is a weak filter for this job. In O*NET's survey of what the occupation requires of new hires, 48% of respondents said an associate's degree, 17% said a high school diploma, and 14% said a post-secondary certificate. A degree requirement in your ad will screen out capable people, and it tells you little about whether someone can format a pleading.

Where you look determines how fast you hire, what you pay beyond wages, and who carries the employment paperwork.

Scroll sideways to see all columns.

RouteHow it worksFits whenCheck before you sign
Direct hireYou advertise, screen and employ the personYou want a long-term employee in the office and have time to run a searchYour state's rules on pay ranges in job ads, and who will run the skills test
Staffing agency, temporary or temp to hireThe agency employs the secretary and bills you an hourly rate that includes its margin; you may convert the person to your payroll laterYou need coverage for leave or a trial, or want to try someone before committingThe conversion fee schedule, the minimum hours before conversion, and whether the agency tested legal skills or only typing
Staffing agency, direct placementA recruiter finds candidates and you pay a fee, usually a percentage of first-year salary, when one startsThe role is senior and your own ads have not produced candidatesThe guarantee period if the hire leaves, and whether the fee is refundable or replaced with a new search
Dedicated remote legal secretary through a legal staffing companyThe company recruits and vets the person, who works full time for your firm on your systems under your supervisionThe work is document, calendar and correspondence work that does not need a body in the officeWho the candidates are, how replacement works, time zone coverage, and how confidentiality and access are handled

Hiring a freelance secretary as an independent contractor is a fifth route, and a narrow one. Someone who works your hours, on your systems, under your direction may be an employee under federal or state tests regardless of what the contract says. The Department of Labor's misclassification page explains the federal side, and state tests are often stricter.

DocketHire fills the fourth route. It places dedicated remote legal secretaries with US law firms starting at $8 per hour, typically sends a shortlist within 5 to 10 business days, and offers unlimited replacements for active engagements. At 2,080 hours a year, $8 per hour comes to $16,640. The legal secretary and virtual legal secretary pages list the tasks and software those placements cover.

Test the work before you talk about it

Interviews reward people who interview well. For a job that consists of producing accurate documents on deadline, a sample of the work tells you more.

The research on hiring methods supports that order. Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens reanalyzed decades of selection studies in the Journal of Applied Psychology in 2022. As summarized by the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology in its review of the paper, the strongest predictors of job performance were structured interviews (operational validity of .42), job knowledge tests (.40), empirically keyed biodata (.38) and work sample tests (.33). The figures are taken from that summary, not from the paper's own tables.

A legal secretary screen can combine a work sample and a job knowledge test in about an hour. Build it from your own closed matters with names changed.

  1. Format a pleading. Give a plain text draft and a copy of the caption and formatting rule for your main court. Ask for a filed-ready document with correct caption, line spacing, page numbers, a signature block and a certificate of service. For appellate or federal work, add a table of contents and a table of authorities generated in Word.
  2. Redact a filing. Hand over an exhibit that contains a Social Security number, a birth date, a minor's name and a bank account number. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2(a), unless the court orders otherwise, a federal filing may include only the last four digits of a Social Security or taxpayer identification number, the year of an individual's birth, a minor's initials, and the last four digits of a financial account number. See whether the candidate finds all four without being told what to look for.
  3. Calendar from a notice. Provide a hearing notice and a scheduling order. Ask the candidate to list every date that should go on the calendar, who should be reminded, and which entries a lawyer should confirm. The right answer includes asking a lawyer about anything computed from a rule.
  4. Proofread a letter. Plant errors in a client letter: a wrong case number, a misspelled party name, a date that does not match its day of the week, and an inconsistent defined term. Count what is caught.
  5. Transcribe three minutes of dictation, if your lawyers dictate. Score accuracy on names, citations and numbers ahead of speed.

Score each part on a written scale before you see the next candidate's work, and give every candidate the same materials and the same time limit. A typing speed figure on its own says little, because the errors that hurt a firm are a wrong date or an unredacted account number, not a slow paragraph.

Follow the test with a structured interview: the same questions for everyone, asked in the same order, with notes on what a strong answer contains. Useful questions ask for specifics. Which courts have you e-filed in, and what happened the last time a filing was rejected? Walk me through what you do when a lawyer hands you a brief at 4 p.m. that is due at midnight. What do you do when a client calls and asks whether they should accept an offer?

The last question has one acceptable answer, which is that the secretary does not give legal advice and gets the question to the lawyer.

Classify the job before the offer letter

Most legal secretaries are entitled to overtime, and paying a salary does not change that.

The federal administrative exemption has three parts, set out in the Department of Labor's Fact Sheet 17C: payment on a salary or fee basis at no less than the standard salary level, a primary duty of office or non-manual work "directly related to the management or general business operations of the employer or the employer's customers," and a primary duty that "includes the exercise of discretion and independent judgment with respect to matters of significance." The department's salary level page lists the standard level as "$684 per week (equivalent to a $35,568 annual salary)."

Most legal secretaries clear the salary level and fail the duties test. 29 CFR 541.202(e) says the exercise of discretion and independent judgment "does not include clerical or secretarial work, recording or tabulating data, or performing other mechanical, repetitive, recurrent or routine work." The regulation does describe one kind of assistant who generally meets the duties test, in 29 CFR 541.203(d): "An executive assistant or administrative assistant to a business owner or senior executive of a large business generally meets the duties requirements for the administrative exemption if such employee, without specific instructions or prescribed procedures, has been delegated authority regarding matters of significance." A secretary who formats and files what lawyers hand over, in a firm of any size, is hard to fit into that sentence.

The related professional exemption does not help either. 29 CFR 541.301(e)(7) says "Paralegals and legal assistants generally do not qualify as exempt learned professionals."

Budget for it. At the O*NET median of $26.72 per hour, time and a half is $40.08, so five extra hours in a trial week cost about $200. Track hours from the first day, including evening e-filings and weekend emails. States can set higher salary levels and stricter duties tests than the federal rule, so have employment counsel confirm the classification where you operate.

Screen for conflicts and run the background check correctly

A legal secretary who has worked at another firm brings that firm's confidential information along. Comment 4 to ABA Model Rule 1.10 addresses this directly. The firm is not disqualified from a matter merely because "the person prohibited from involvement in a matter is a nonlawyer, such as a paralegal or legal secretary," but the comment continues: "Such persons, however, ordinarily must be screened from any personal participation in the matter to avoid communication to others in the firm of confidential information that both the nonlawyers and the firm have a legal duty to protect." The quotation is from North Carolina's adopted version of the comment, and your state's rule may differ.

In practice, ask every finalist for a list of prior legal employers and, without asking for confidential details, the adverse parties on matters they worked on that your firm is also involved in. Run the names through your conflicts system before the start date and document any screen you set up.

If you order a background report through a screening company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act sets the steps. The Federal Trade Commission's guidance for employers says you must tell the applicant that you might use the report for employment decisions, and "This notice must be in writing and in a stand-alone format." You also need written permission. Before rejecting someone because of the report, you must give them a copy of it and a summary of their rights, and afterward a notice that names the reporting company. Some states and cities add their own limits on criminal history and credit checks.

Supervise from the first day

Under ABA Model Rule 5.3, partners and lawyers with comparable managerial authority must make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures "giving reasonable assurance" that a nonlawyer's conduct "is compatible with the professional obligations of the lawyer," and the lawyer who directly supervises the secretary has a parallel duty. The rule applies the same way to an employee down the hall and a remote secretary in another time zone.

A short first-month checklist covers most of it:

  • A signed confidentiality agreement and a walk through the firm's rules on client information, including what may never be sent to a personal email account or pasted into a public AI tool.
  • An individual login for every system, with access limited to the matters and functions the job needs.
  • Written instructions for e-filing. In federal court, Rule 5(d)(3)(C) treats "a filing made through a person's electronic-filing account and authorized by that person" as signed by that person once the name is on the signature block, so the lawyer whose account is used owns every filing the secretary submits. Set a rule that nothing is filed without that lawyer's sign-off on the final PDF.
  • A calendar rule: the secretary enters dates from notices and orders, and a lawyer confirms any deadline computed from a rule or statute.
  • A weekly review for the first 90 days in which the supervising lawyer checks a sample of filings, calendar entries and letters and gives corrections in writing.

The onboarding plan generator builds a 30, 60 and 90 day schedule around these points, and the supervision plan builder does the same for a remote or outsourced arrangement.

Where to start this week

  1. Sort two weeks of your lawyers' administrative work into the three columns above and count the hours.
  2. Look up the BLS wage for legal secretaries in your state and metro area and set a range around it, with overtime in the budget.
  3. Build the one-hour skills test from a closed matter.
  4. Pick a route: your own ad, an agency, or a remote placement.

If the work fits a remote secretary, tell us the courts, software and practice areas involved when you book a meeting, and DocketHire will respond within one business day.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

How much does a legal secretary cost?

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports a median annual wage of $55,570 for legal secretaries and administrative assistants in May 2025, which O*NET lists as $26.72 per hour. The employer share of Social Security and Medicare tax adds 7.65%, about $4,251 a year at the median, before health insurance, paid leave, unemployment insurance, equipment and office space. Pay varies by city, practice area and experience, so check the BLS figures for your state and metropolitan area before setting a range.

Is a legal secretary exempt from overtime?

Usually not. The federal administrative exemption requires a primary duty that includes the exercise of discretion and independent judgment with respect to matters of significance, and 29 CFR 541.202(e) says that this "does not include clerical or secretarial work, recording or tabulating data, or performing other mechanical, repetitive, recurrent or routine work." Paying a salary does not change the result. State law can be stricter than federal law, so confirm the classification with employment counsel.

What skills should a legal secretary have?

The O*NET task list for the occupation centers on preparing, proofreading and processing legal documents such as summonses, subpoenas, complaints, appeals and motions, plus filing, scheduling, correspondence, client billing and records collection. In practice that means advanced Microsoft Word formatting, knowledge of your courts' filing and formatting rules, accurate calendaring, redaction of personal identifiers, and clear written communication with clients and court staff.

What is the difference between a legal secretary and a paralegal?

A legal secretary produces and files documents, manages calendars and correspondence, and keeps files in order. A paralegal performs substantive legal work under a lawyer's supervision, such as drafting discovery responses, summarizing records and preparing exhibits. Small firms often combine the two in one job. Neither may give legal advice, and under ABA Model Rule 5.3 the supervising lawyer remains responsible for the work of both.

Can a legal secretary work remotely?

Yes. Document preparation, e-filing, calendaring, dictation, billing entry and file management all run through software a remote secretary can reach with an individual login. The supervising lawyer's duties under ABA Model Rule 5.3 are the same wherever the person sits, so remote arrangements need written procedures, access controls and a regular review of the work.

Need Help With Your Law Firm Staffing?

DocketHire provides trained legal virtual assistants starting at $8/hr. No long-term contracts.

Explore related DocketHire hubs

Share this article